← Back to Articles

Co-op vs. Condo in NYC

Buying Guide • 12 min read

If you're buying residential real estate in Manhattan, you'll encounter two primary ownership structures: co-ops and condos. These aren't minor variations—they represent fundamentally different ways of owning property, with distinct financial, legal, and lifestyle implications.

Understanding the difference isn't optional. It affects everything from how much you'll pay upfront to whether you can rent out your apartment or secure financing. Here's what matters.

The Core Distinction

Co-ops: Buying Shares in a Corporation

When you "buy" a co-op apartment, you're not actually buying real estate. You're purchasing shares in a corporation that owns the building. Those shares entitle you to a proprietary lease, giving you the right to occupy a specific unit.

This structure has significant implications. You're a shareholder in a corporation, which means you're subject to the corporation's rules (the proprietary lease and house rules). The board of directors—elected by shareholders—has considerable authority over building operations, finances, and who can purchase apartments.

Condos: Owning a Deed

Condo ownership is more straightforward. When you buy a condo, you own the physical unit and receive a deed—the same as buying a house. You also own a percentage of the building's common elements (lobby, hallways, roof, mechanical systems).

This ownership structure means more autonomy. While condo buildings have boards and rules, their authority is more limited compared to co-op boards.

Financial Implications

Purchase Price

Co-ops typically sell for 10-30% less than comparable condos in the same neighborhood. This discount reflects the restrictions and complications that come with co-op ownership. If two nearly identical apartments sit next door to each other—one co-op, one condo—the condo will command higher pricing.

This creates a meaningful affordability difference, particularly in expensive neighborhoods where that 20% discount can represent hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Monthly Carrying Costs

Both co-ops and condos charge monthly fees, but the structure differs:

Co-op maintenance: This covers building operations, staff salaries, repairs, and the building's underlying mortgage and property taxes. Because it includes taxes, co-op maintenance tends to be higher than condo common charges. The good news: the portion covering property taxes and mortgage interest is typically tax-deductible.

Condo common charges: This covers building operations and reserves but doesn't include property taxes (you pay those separately) or any building mortgage (most condos don't have one). Monthly common charges appear lower, but you're also paying property taxes directly.

When comparing total monthly costs, co-ops and condos often land in similar territory—the structure just differs.

Financing

Co-ops: Stricter financing requirements. Many co-op boards require 20-30% down payments and won't accept FHA or VA loans. Some buildings have even higher requirements—30, 40, or 50% down. This limits your financing options and can make it harder to preserve capital for other investments.

Condos: Standard mortgage financing applies. You can put down as little as 10-20% (or even less with certain loan programs), and lenders treat condos the same as single-family homes.

Board Approval Process

Co-ops: Extensive Scrutiny

Co-op board approval is rigorous. After your offer is accepted, you'll submit a board package that typically includes:

• Personal and professional reference letters
• Employment verification and salary information
• Tax returns (usually 2-3 years)
• Bank and investment account statements
• Credit report
• Detailed personal and professional biography

The board reviews this package, and if they approve it, you'll be invited to an interview. This is typically a 20-45 minute session where board members ask about your background, financial situation, and plans for the apartment.

Boards can reject buyers for almost any reason (except protected discrimination categories). They don't need to explain their decision. If you're rejected, your contract is cancelled and your deposit is returned—but you've wasted weeks of time and possibly lost other opportunities.

Condos: Limited Review

Most condo buildings have a "right of first refusal" rather than full board approval. You submit a simpler package (financial docs, background info), and the board can either approve the sale or purchase the unit themselves at your offer price.

In practice, boards rarely exercise this right. Condo approval is closer to a formality—assuming your financials support the purchase, you'll almost certainly be approved.

Subletting and Flexibility

Co-ops: Restrictive

Co-op sublet policies vary widely. Some buildings prohibit subletting entirely. Others allow it but with restrictions:

• Minimum ownership periods before subletting (often 1-2 years)
• Maximum sublet duration (commonly 2-3 years out of every 5)
• Board approval of subtenants (with similar scrutiny to purchase applications)
• Sublet fees (often 3-10% of annual rent paid to the building)

If you think you might need to relocate for work, rent out the unit, or use it as an investment property, co-op restrictions can be deal-breakers.

Condos: Flexible

Most condos allow subletting with minimal restrictions. You might need to notify the board or pay a small flip tax (typically 1-3% of sale price), but outright prohibitions are rare.

This flexibility matters if your life circumstances might change—job relocation, extended travel, or wanting rental income. Condos accommodate these situations more easily.

Pied-à-Terre Purchases

If you're buying a secondary residence in New York while maintaining a primary home elsewhere, co-ops create complications. Many buildings explicitly prohibit pied-à-terre purchases or require that the apartment be your primary residence.

Condos rarely have these restrictions. If you're buying as a second home, condos offer a clearer path.

Building Control and Governance

Co-ops: Stronger Board Authority

Co-op boards have significant power over building operations and individual shareholders. They can:

• Approve or reject prospective buyers
• Approve or reject subtenants
• Restrict renovations, including what work requires approval
• Impose assessments for building improvements
• Create and enforce house rules on everything from pet policies to move-in/out scheduling

This creates a more controlled environment. If you want a building where everyone is vetted and rules are enforced, co-ops provide that structure. If you want more autonomy, the level of board control can feel intrusive.

Condos: Limited Board Power

Condo boards have authority over common areas and can create rules, but their power over individual unit owners is limited. You have more freedom to renovate, sublet, and use your apartment as you see fit.

The trade-off: less control over who your neighbors are and how the building operates.

Which Is Right for You?

Consider a co-op if:

• You're buying your primary residence and plan to live there long-term
• You want a more controlled, stable building environment
• You can meet strict financial requirements (20-50% down)
• You don't need flexibility to sublet or use as pied-à-terre
• You want to maximize value (co-ops trade at a discount to condos)

Consider a condo if:

• You want more flexibility with subletting and use
• You're buying as an investment or pied-à-terre
• You want easier financing (10-20% down)
• You want a simpler, faster approval process
• You value autonomy over board control

Common Misconceptions

"Condos are always newer and nicer."
Not necessarily. Plenty of beautiful pre-war co-ops exist, and plenty of mediocre condos were built in the 2000s. Quality varies within both categories.

"Co-op boards are always difficult."
Board temperament varies widely. Some are professional and efficient. Others are intrusive and difficult. Research the specific building's reputation before committing.

"Condos have no restrictions."
While condos are less restrictive than co-ops, they still have rules, board approval processes, and house policies. Read the offering plan and bylaws carefully.

"You can't get approved for a co-op."
If your finances are solid and you present yourself professionally, most co-op boards will approve you. The process is rigorous, but it's not impossible.

Making the Decision

The co-op vs. condo decision isn't about which is "better"—it's about which aligns with your situation, finances, and priorities.

Before you start looking at apartments, clarify your answers to these questions:

• Is this your primary residence or a pied-à-terre?
• How much can you put down (and how much do you want to)?
• Do you need flexibility to sublet?
• How important is board approval certainty vs. price savings?
• What's your timeline for potential life changes?

Your answers will point you toward the structure that fits. From there, you can focus on finding the right unit within that category rather than second-guessing the ownership type.